Video after the jump.
Video after the jump.
The hyper-loquacious and ever-ubiquitous Mark Shea writes the following:
Jennifer Roback Morse, one of the most reviled advocates of common sense in America, shouts into the gale force winds of "What could it possibly hurt?" attempting prevent us from reaching the "How were we supposed to know?" phase of history.Will do! Episode 1 below, episodes 2-4 on YouTube.
For more, check out the Dept. of Evangelization and Catechesis for the Diocese of Sacramento.
Check it thou out!My name is Matt Fradd, I'm the founder of a Catholic website called www.theporneffect.com which is the most comprehensive anti-porn site for Catholics. I wanted to point you to two of my talks which you are welcome to use.
I have a talk on porn giving my own testimony, a talk on Mary called "my mother is a virgin" and an interview on porn I did with Catholic Answers Live.Let me know what you think.
--
Matt Fradd
www.netministries.ie
www.theporneffect.com
Male and Female, He Created Them: Apologetics for Same Sex Attraction
Download | Duration: 00:57:29
Homosexuality: Why Not-Dr. Janet SmithOn Wednesday, May 27th, the Gospel of Life Group at Our Lady of Good Counsel Parish hosted Dr. Janet Smith as part of the Dignity of Life Speaker Series. Professor Smith holds the Father Michael J. McGivney Chair of Life Ethics at Sacred Heart Major Seminary.
Click Below to Play Podcast:Download | Duration: 01:53:01
Thank you for listening to the National Fellowship of Catholic Men Online Media Network. Our mission is to encourage the conversion, formation and mobilization of Catholic men. For more information visit www.catholicmediaonline.org .
Don't forget to subscribe to this podcast so that it is automatically downloaded to your computer!
Petr responded by pointing to the following:
Video Clip #1
Video Clip #2
Video Clip #3
Mason C. also wrote in and pointed to this piece at the EPPC:
The Question of Marriage
A Lecture by Hadley ArkesIn this lecture, Professor Hadley Arkes explained how the most serious challenge in principle to the traditional laws governing marriage in fact reveals the deeper flaws in the argument for same-sex marriage.
AUDIO RECORDING OF THIS EVENT
Event audio, part one (MP3 format, 41 megabytes, 75 minutes)
Event audio, part two (MP3 format, 2 megabytes, 4 minutes)
Hadley Arkes (full bio here) is an EPPC Senior Fellow, and the Edward Ney Professor American Institutions at Amherst College. His most recent book is Natural Rights and the Right to Choose (Cambridge University Press, 2002).
Thanks!!
To date, it's the most concise summary of the non-religious-based arguments I've read regarding why all this same sex "marriage" nonsense deserves to be shouted out of the public square. Do yourself a favor and give it a read -- that way, the next time that guy at work says, "Everone should just be allowed to do whatever they want," you'll have a good answer to provide that he'll accept, even if he's an atheist.
If someone could point me to a good audio file which gives these same points (more or less) it would be greatly appreciated.
My “Debate” With Bishop Gumbleton on Gays in the Priesthood
A couple of years ago, I was asked to appear on a secular talk-radio show to discuss the issue of homosexuals in the priesthood with now-retired Bishop Thomas Gumbleton, a perennial fixture within the “progressive” fringe of
dissenting Catholics. He argued the case that homosexuals in the priesthood is no problem at all. I, as you might guess, said exactly the opposite. It was a brief discussion, only about 20 minutes (including a commercial break), but long enough to see two very different approaches to this important issue. What are your thoughts?
Listen to the show here:
Part one
Here are some things you can find by clicking through the links:Might I suggest adding the links of Maggie Gallagher's media appearances (page found here): http://www.marriagedebate.com/archives/archives_mg.php
She is a great speaker and frames the debate in a manner only a sociologist could
Mrs. Gallagher is a faithful Catholic and President of the Institute of Marriage and Public Policy.
| Will Same-Sex Marriage Hurt America? Maggie Gallagher, Institute for Marriage and Public Policy Jonathan Rauch, Senior Writer and Columnist, National Journal University of Washington 3/9/2005 From ISI's Cicero's Podium: A Great Issues Debate Series. |
|
Same-Sex Marriage and the Laws Maggie Gallagher · April 13, 2004
A nationally syndicated columnist, author of The Case for Marriage, and a leader in the fight to preserve traditional marriage, Maggie Gallagher gives her views, and some sociological evidence, for why traditional marriage between a man and a woman ought to be maintained.
| Maggie Gallagher. · 1:35'39" |
Ok. I could have posted that in the combox. Why take up a post? Because we need to do more than just put forth religious arguments. Most of the folks ranting about this don't care what religious arguments are out there. Most of the folks ranting about this are so damaged they don't care about God at all. Ahh...there but for the grace of God go I. It's important to remember that without God's grace we wouldn't care either. But I digress.
So what's the secular argument against so-called same-sex marriage?
I'm glad you asked.
We'll start with a brief recitation of why marriage was recognized by the government to begin with. It wasn't about love and it wasn't about religion. It was about controlling how baby-making activity takes place.
Let me 'splain. Men and women are going to have sex whether the government is involved or not. That's just how we're wired. Call it evolutionary instinct if it makes you feel better. Now...there are two ways for people to go about having sex. The first way is for a guy to irresponsibly dip his wick in whatever pot he finds. That makes for lots of single moms and fatherless kids. As it turns out, every study done on the subject shows conclusively that this is really bad for everyone involved, psychologically, sociologically and epidemiologically. The second way is for the man and woman (or several women, for that matter - but there are different reasons why that's bad) to have sex in a committed, life-long relationship. This provides stability for the mother and a male/female role-model set for the child. It also keeps men and women living longer, happier, more productive li
Query: does the government have an interest in encouraging the optimal situation above to happen?
Answer: Yup.
As a result, the government started recognizing - in fact, incentivizing, and at great expense - marriage between heterosexuals. Are some infertile? Sure. But odds are that one of the two is fertile and as long as that's typical (which it is) this still encourages baby-making activity occuring in a responsible way.
Enter same sex marriage arguments, stage left.
First, a negative argument:
What's the government interest in same-sex unions? We've seen what it is in heterosexual marriage - making sure procreatively ordered sex happens in a responsible way. What's the government interest in what's basically mutual masturbation? I just don't see one. At the very least, I don't see an interest more significant than the interest in the relationship between my brothers and me.
Until someone gives me a logical reason to the contrary, I'm inclined to think my tax dollars should not be spent incentivizing something the government has no interest in. You gays want to shack up? I'm not going to stop you. You gays want to proclaim youselves indesoluably joined at the Online Church of Babalouay? Hey, it's a free country. Want me to make sure you're entitled to your lover's social security payment after he dies? Um...no. Same goes for a tax break. Same goes for instant citizenship. As a taxpayer concerned about my tax dollars, that just doesn't make sense. Call me when there's a reason beyond two people liking one another and maybe then I'll give you access to my pocketbook. Besides, any fool who's been married longer than the honeymoon can tell you that marriage is definitely not linked to liking the other person!
Second, a positive argument:
The government should strengthen marriage between a man and a woman, not reduce it to the level of an ordinary contract. Would a good step be eliminating no-fault divorce? You betcha'! I'm all for it. In fact, I'd favor a one-shot marriage measure that would say (absent abuse charges being pressed or a time-limited annullment) if you divorce you never get government recognition of your marriage again. I'd say we need that as well as an even stronger incentive package for married folks - something like a drop in tax rate of 5% for every 10 years married. But the strengthing plan isn't in front of us -- the not weakening marriage plan is.
With the skyrocketted divorce rate and the associated societal harm (insert innumerable studies here), I hardly think I have to defend why the government should be encouraging a return to a stronger view of marriage. At the very least, refusing to recognize same sex so-called marriages on the grounds that they're not procreative might just remind some folks why the government started recognizing marriage to begin with. And that might just avoid a demographic winter, which is sort of a good thing for a society to desire.
So yeah, I think Prop 8 came out the right way and if a Catholic disagrees they're not using their thinking cap.
Now there are plenty of other arguments to be had in this area, like the simple fact that same sex so-called marriage is not a "right" - if it were, where would it come from? God? The Constitution? The simple fact of your humanity, a fact most of you find insufficient to grant the weakest of us freedom from being dismembered or burned to death with saline in the womb? And then there's the argument about what my kids get taught in public school -- "It's not enough that you tolerate," as Mark Shea says, "You. MUST. Accept!"
...But again I digress...
What I mean to say is that there are other arguments that I'm not going into because I don't really think we need to (and I've gone on long enough already). What we need to do is present secular arguments for the secular audience. Meet them where they're at. To those under the law and whatnot. And so far we haven't done it...which is why, despite winning a few battles, we're losing the war.
Here are some .wma videos from Catholic Parents OnLine
If you think you may need them, please do check them out.Summer 2002 Show (Truth about Homosexuality #1) Summer 2002 Show (Homosexuality/Courage #2) Summer 2002 Show (Homosexuality/Courage #3)
Also, here's a program from DoxaPod Audio:
The March 30, 2008 episode of Sunday Night Live (on the Eternal Word Television Network). Hosted by Fr. Benedict Groeschel with guest Fr. John Harvey and Fr. Paul Check: The Courage Movement. Duration: 56 minutes.
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Old Glory Radio interview with Charlotte Robinson, Boston Ma., Emmy Award Winning Producer, (CBS, ABC news) about her new pro- Gay Marriage film via: OUTTAKEonline.com - 02/07/08
I'll give it a listen. I typically find it's worthwhile to hear others present their side so that our dialog can be focused more narrowly on rebutting their claims and addressing their concerns. If you aren't listening when they speak you can't reply -- you can only try to scream louder. I'm just hoping that this is presented well...but unfortunately I find that's seldom the case...
Here's the audio: Download
*HT to Charlotte Robinson (one and the same from OUTTAKEonline.com), who sent this in.
UPDATE: I listened to the roughly 20 minute interview and have a few comments.
1. When asked why the logic of "marriage is a civil right available to anyone who wants it with anyone they want" ought not apply to polygamy (polyandry, polygyny or group marriage), the rather unsatisfying response was, more or less, because that's not what we're talking about -- we're only talking about two people.
That's more or less the same as asking why should gravity not apply to oranges when it clearly applies to apples and receiving the answer, "Well, we're not talking oranges. We're talking apples." True, we may only be talking about apples, but if the logic works then it applies equally. What's good for the goose is good for the gander...unless you want to be discriminatory and un-inclusive...which is why Justice Scalia wrote what he did in his dissent in Lawrence v. Texas.
2. When asked about what rights marriage provides that civil unions don't, no specifics were given. They're available, but one would expect a proponent to be able to rattle them off. Disappointing, but not fatal to the argument -- just the credibility of the presenter (though, in fairness, it may have been a tactical decision). When you look at the differences, they mainly have to do with
(a) immigration rights,
(b) taxation, and
(c) Social Security benefits.
The proper response (I suppose) would be to ask why these ought to be granted to same-sex couples. With opposite sex couples the incentives were created to
(a) increase future generations of Americans (raised by both biological parents),Same sex couples do not have the capacity for a fruitful union (while opposite sex couples typically do have the capacity for fecundity), and therefore normatively will not
(b) to favor models where one spouse tends the children while the other spouse works, and
(c) to provide for a spouse who, having stayed at home to tend the children, does not have a gainful source of employment.
(a) increase future generations of Americans (raised by both biological parents -- as it stands, begetting children still requires both a man AND a woman),
(b) require a spouse to stay home to raise kids they don't beget, or
(c) require a spouse to sacrifice career for kids they never begot in the first place.
To the rebuttal that we allow infertile couples to marry I would say the following: (1) to require a fertility test would likely be an invasion of privacy under the famed privacy penumbra of the Constitution justifying abortion and contraception, and (2) even "infertile" couples sometimes conceive. Additionally, even infertile heterosexual couples are still of the same kind as fertile couples, whereas same-sex couples are different in kind.
To the rebuttal that same-sex couples often bring children into the relationship, I would say the following: (1) children do best across the board (absent abuse/neglect) in households with both biological parents present (therefore, those are the types of relationships the government should incentivize) and (2) justifying marriage because there are two caretakers of an already present child would also seem to require governmental acknowledgment of tax benefits, Social Security benefits, etc. where a single mother and her child move in with the single mother's sister. Two caretakers, one child, why not marriage? Remember, what's good for the goose is good for the gander...
So, viewed through this lens, it would seem that IF civil unions were allowed (which I think they ought not be), differences in benefits would still be legitimate under a state's interest test.
3. Building off the last point, is what's being sought a governmental recognition (using your tax dollars) that two people like each other a whole, whole lot? Ought the government to dole out benefits merely on the basis of affection? Really...what is the state's interest in recognizing civil unions at all? There's a clear reason for recognizing marriage -- the good of any potential offspring which are normatively the result of such unions -- but I simply don't see the analog interest for same-sex couples.
4. Most of the non-tax related privileges of marriage can be obtained through free powers of attorney, free wills and joint bank accounts, which, even after you pay the $5 required for a notary public, are less expensive than a marriage license. Hospital visitation rights, health decisions, unlimited financial discretion -- it's all there. No additional legislation required and easy as pie. So why the push?
The answer, of course, is that the law is a teacher. It has a didactic function in society, informing us of where the moral lines are.
Don't believe it? Look at what no-fault divorce laws and mandatory integration laws have wrought, to give examples where I both disagree and agree with the pedagogy. The law deeply and significantly informs our cultural mores. What's being sought is a normalization of same-sex activity, and once legally recognized you can expect your child to have to read And Tango Makes Three before leaving the second grade, making your actual "civil right" of being able to educate your progeny in the way you see fit far more difficult.
5. The interviewee manages to interject racism several times into the argument. This is unfortunate, because it clouds the issue. That is, unless the logic for one implicates the other...and if that's the case, she'd better start addressing polygamy and categorical bans on incestuous marriages between consenting adults.
Of course, there's more...but you begin to see what it takes to rebut a short radio interview...
Dale O'Leary
Priesthood/ Same Sex Attraction (Part 1) (Part2)
Rev. Paul Desmarais
Donna Olobri
Women & Aging (Part 1) (Part2)
Maggie Mahrt
Sr. Jane Culligan
Examination of Conscience (Part 1) (Part2)
Reconciliation (Part 1) (Part2)
Rev. Giacomo Capoverdi, Jr.
Right to Life (Part 1) (Part2)
World Youth Day 2002 (Part 1) (Part2)
Brown Scapular (Part 1) (Part2)
Joyce Percival
Cancer Survivor 1 (Part 1) (Part2)
Cancer Survivor 2 (Part 1) (Part2)
Rev. Marcel Taillon
Priesthood I (Part 1) (Part 2)
Priesthood 2 (Part 1) (Part 2)
Maria Parker
Life Issues 1 (Part 1) (Part2)
Life Issues 2 (Part 1) (Part2)
Mary Sheehan
Georgette Fornay
Molly Parnell
Sr. Dorothy Schwarz
Spiritual Life (Part 1) (Part2)
Sr. Mary Clement
Evangelization 1 (Part 1) (Part2)
Evangelization 2 (Part 1) (Part2)
Rev. Joel Lecuivre
Dona Le Boeuf
Life Issues 1 (Part 1) (Part2)
Life Issues 2 (Part 1) (Part2)
Patricia Wolfert
Susan Boczar
Gabriel Project (Part 1) (Part2)
Arlene Hebert
Creighton NFP 1 (Part 1) (Part2)
Creighton NFP 2 (Part 1) (Part2)
Dr. Donald DeMarco
Rev. Thomas Trepanier
Dr. Jeremiah Lowney
Haitian Health Foundation 1 (Part 1) (Part2)
Haitian Health Foundation 2 (Part 1) (Part2)
Stephen Schwarz
Senator Catherine Graziano
Catholic Legislatures (Part 1) (Part2)
Pro-Life Issues (Part 1) (Part2)
Maureen Hogan
Lora Morgan
Young Adult Ministry (Part 1) (Part2)
Dr. Michelle Cretella
Deacon Stephen Cote
Marriage Prep 1 (Part 1) (Part2)
Marriage Prep 2 (Part 1) (Part2)
Lisa & Keith Kline
Youth Ministry (Part 1) (Part2)
Catholic Marriage (Part 1) (Part2)
Jean Cedor
Brian & Phyllis Calvey
Catholic Story Tellers 1 (Part 1) (Part2)
Catholic Story Tellers 2 (Part 1) (Part2)
Beverly Munyon
Prison Ministry 1 (Part 1) (Part2)
Prison Ministry 2 (Part 1) (Part2)
Joan Pendergast & Dr. Sheila Kuzmik
Rachel’s Vineyard 1 (Part 1) (Part2)
Rachel's Vineyard 2 (Part 1) (Part2)
Kathryn Wrobel
Reconciliation 1 (Part 1) (Part2)
Reconciliation 2 (Part 1) (Part2)
Bud & Kim Miller
Peg Lavallee
RI Right to Life (Part 1) (Part2)
Barbara Burgess
Alberta DiMuccio
Amparo & Lopez
Legion of Mary I (Part 1) (Part2)
Legion of Mary 2 (Part 1) (Part2)
Rev. James Ruggieri & Therese Cotnoir
Blackstone Valley Cath. Worker 1 (Part 1) (Part2)
Blackstone Valley Cath. Worker 2 (Part 1) (Part2)
Madeline Nugent
Saint's Stories (Part 1) (Part2)
Brothers & Sisters of Penance (Part 1) (Part2)
Marian Desrosiers
Lillian McIntyre
St. Philip School (Part 1) (Part2)
Jane Wilcox
Jamie & Matthew Friel
Couple to Couple League (Part 1) (Part2)
Terry Mac Lellan
Natural Family Planning (Part 1) (Part2)
Susan Conroy
Mother Teresa 1 (Part 1) (Part2)
Mother Teresa 2 (Part 1) (Part2)
Mother Teresa Beatification I (Part 1) (Part 2)
Mother Teresa Beatification 2 (Part 1) (Part 2)
Ruth Oakley
Mission Ascent (Part 1) (Part 2)
Genevieve Kineke
Vocation of Women I (Part 1) (Part 2)
Vocation of Women 2 (Part 1) (Part 2)
Vocation of Women 3 (Part 1) (Part 2)
Vocation of Women 4 (Part 1) (Part 2)
Vocation of Women 5 (Part 1) (Part 2)
Vocation of Women 6 (Part 1) (Part 2)